Hillsong vs. Getty: A Contrast in Melody-Writing

Zac HicksConvergence of Old and New in Worship, Personal Stories & Testimonies, Worship Style, Worship Theology & Thought5 Comments

Circulating through many of my favorite worship blogs is the distillation of Keith Getty’s presentation on songwriting at the National Worship Leaders Conference.  It is getting widespread press for good reason—Getty’s insights are golden.  With particular regards to melody-writing, Getty had to say:

“To write strong melodies remember that folk melody has to be passed on orally (aurally). I try to write songs that can be sung with no written music. I imitate Irish folk melody, with a great deal of contour, of rise and fall.”

When I first heard Getty talk about this in January at the Calvin Symposium on Christian Worship, my mind was immediately flooded with the modern worship songs which don’t live up to this criterion and yet seem to still gain momentum in churches.  Of particular prominence in my mind was the material of Hillsong and Hillsong United.  Many of their songs’ melodies would fall flat without their music.  And, though filled with melodic leaps, I would not characterize their vocal lines as having “a great deal of contour, of rise and fall”…at least in the way that I understand Getty to mean it.

When I hear the melodies of Getty, I am always struck by their melismatic richness and flowing elegance.  They are “easy on the voice.”  They rise and fall step-wise with minimal intervallic gaps.  Leaps, when they happen, are intentional and cautiously used (“In Christ Alone” would be a perfect example of this).  Such melodies certainly stir the senses and move the heart.  They arouse the more elegant folk sensibilities in me.  To describe them in a nutshell: Getty’s melodies express through refined artistic beauty.

When I hear the melodies of Hillsong, I am always struck by their emotional immediacy and speech-like, colloquial accessibility.  There is something more basic and instinctual in me that resonates with the stuttering rhythms and jolting intervals that characterize the melodies of Hillsong (for an example of this, listen to “Freedom is Here”).   Their melodies arouse the more earthy, “tribal” sensibilities in me.  To describe them in a nutshell: Hillsong’s melodies express through raw human emotion.

Must these worlds be at odds?  Some say yes.  My more intelligent and analytical friends would be quick to (correctly) point out that the melodies of Getty will stand the test of time while those of Hillsong won’t.  In their minds, it would logically follow that, for that reason, one should favor Getty.  But, while my classical training and artistic sensibilities agree with this, on an existential level I can honestly say that something basic to my humanness would go unexpressed if all I sang were the refined, lyrical melodies of Getty.  Folk-influenced melodies pull back some of the emotive punch I would want to express in my musical worship unto God.  Sometimes, with Hillsong melodies, they come close to being shouts barely bound by pitch and key…and any honest reading of the Psalms shows that Scripture affirms this type of raw emotion.

I’ve noted that my more artsy friends have been quick to dismiss much of the Hillsong repertoire because it lacks melodic and musical sophistication, so they say.  They consider it poor songwriting.  But I wonder whether their criteria are formed in an artistic bubble such that they can’t see the obvious evidence: Hillsong’s music is sought after and passionately sung by (I would speculate) millions of people globally (yes, even in non-Western countries…check out their “I Heart Revolution” DVD).  Hear me out.  This is not as simple as an it’s-popular-so-we-should-do-it argument.  It has more to do with how the rhythms and contours of the melodies (wedded, of course, with the texts) tap into something deep in the human spirit (check out Sarah Mac’s post saying this very thing). 

Let me put it another way.  As I think about the complex faculties that make up my humanness, I can make this observation: With Getty’s music, my brain sings; with Hillsong’s music, my gut sings.  Again, I am talking about melody, not text.  When I hear/sing these melodies, different faculties in me are stirred emotionally.  With Getty, my refined, cerebral emotion is stimulated.  With Hillsong, my basic, instinctual emotion is stimulated.

Here’s where this all gets intensely personal for me.  I’ve been planning and visioneering our second hymns album (which we’ll begin production on in January 2011, Lord-willing), and I’m settling on a songwriting and production approach which mirrors much more what Hillsong is doing from a musical standpoint.  My hope is to make hymns palatable to Hillsong junkies and modern worship exclusivists.  More than that, I’m excited to move into uncharted waters in the convergence of old hymns to modern music—not only am I writing hymn-tunes which are “contemporary” and accompanied by rock band instrumentation, I am writing them in a contemporary style that many think is impossible (or foolish) to wed with such texts.  The people-pleasing side of me (which I need to repent of) knows that I will not be looked upon favorably by the hymns movement guys and gals I so respect and admire, because they tend to fall in line with Getty’s melody-writing philosophies (not to say that their albums and production all sound the same, because they don’t).  So perhaps my above reflections are an attempt to justify the musical validity not just of Hillsong but of my own new risky endeavor.

What’s frustrating to me is that I don’t hear anyone talking about this kind of thing.  Just as there have been worship wars between traditional and modern music sentimentalities, so I’m witnessing mounting polarities between mainstream modern worship and the modern hymns movement types.  I desperately want the camps to come together, mainly so that the latter can speak into the former.  But right now, there’s a lot of critical rhetoric out there from the hymns movement folks without any counterbalancing of encouragement and appreciation.  The hymns movement is reacting to mainstream modern worship prophetically (which is not without merit), but they need to couple that with a pastoral approach, as well.

I’ll conclude with a fictional encounter that illustrates my fear: While having coffee with some leading figure in the hymns movement, I ask them “So what do you think of Hillsong?”  They either respond with, “Hill-Who?” or “I don’t listen to that trash.”

5 Comments on “Hillsong vs. Getty: A Contrast in Melody-Writing”

  1. Nice article Zac.

    I think your observation is acurate and, while I also approach the debate from a more conservative frame of mind, I am sometimes embarrassed by the (at times) arrogant stance taken by the supporters (zealots) of modern hymnody. Have we forgotten that the first recorded song in the bible is Miriams’ spontaneous ‘folk’ rendition; passionately celebrating God’s deliverance (Ex 15:20–21).

    I think we must be careful when we make such ‘prophetic’ declarations such as ‘Getty’s music will stand the test of time – but Hillsong’s repertoire willl fade with time.’ We must remember that all will fade away (1 Cor 13:8–10)…yes even hymnody!

    Again, thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts.

  2. Maybe I am just getting older, but I find the people I am around tend to resonate more with the Red Mountain/ Sandra McCracken stuff that both Hillsong or Getty. When I ask why that is, I get the same response, Hillsong, Getty, Tomlin, Redman, are all still too "pop" sounding for them. They prefer the folky/indie sound of the Red Mountain stuff. So for some people it just narrows down to preference. Nothing more.

    For what its worth, your work is better than Hillsong. It does not have that adolescent pop feel to it. I think it is because you listen to such a wide variety of artists.

  3. Zac,
    Keep plugging away dude. Our boy Don always said that it wasn’t his giftedness that got him along in ministry, but his plodding nature. He stayed faithful to God, to family, and to his call. If this is your call, then just keep plugging away.

    Btw, I don’t think hymnody or worship music will pass away, given the amount of worship that seems to be emanating from heaven in the book of Revelation. Also, if demons are scared by "A Mighty Fortress is our God," there must be some eternal value to what you’re doing. I therefore disagree with poster #1.

    Peace out.
    Dave S.

  4. i'm sorry….. i cant speak of english more better than it…
    i'm from indonesia, i just know a half of your message on this post… that u more bored from hillsong music dominate… i'm sorry, i dont know anything about music… i just worship God just with humble heart as long as i know that i am His son… and Hillsong has make me know WHO IS GOD… and so far it's allright!!

    so i just say i respect what you say… but i think you must more respect their song with the Heart… worship God with Heart and mind as equal but once again with your body… if your body cant talk about rock and roll, just let it go! don't make a new trash rule, who make a portal some one to not worhip God… i believe Hillsong UNITED has comes because the are YOUTH PEOPLE who inspired GOD to sing a worship song with HEART to know about more GOD for other people and SHARE it to many YOUTH community in worldwide as me and my friend, and it has BLESS my church and my city and my country… so i dont think that its about good performance, or good song, or good lyric or Money seller but i thin its all about PASSION to worship GOD

    so whats wrong with HILLSONG? NEITHER, aren't HYMEN SONG not cool??? NO, it's still bless my country (like amazing grace) and the man who FEAR OF GOD, i believe they are NEVER made this case be a BIG PROBLEMS ?/ if u know my country, u will be supriese how can christian can be stand until NOW…

    with peace of God
    from INDONESIA
    PEOPLE OF PASSION

  5. HEngky: Thanks for your thoughts! I think the language barrier may be present here, just because it sounds like you didn't understand what I was saying, based on your reaction.

    Nevertheless, may God grant His grace and peace to the church in Indonesia!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.